whisper-vs-groq
Public benchmark: which speech-to-text provider is fastest AND most accurate on UK phone audio?
§ 01 · What it is
A rigorous head-to-head benchmark of speech-to-text providers (OpenAI Whisper, Groq Whisper Turbo, Deepgram Nova-3, AssemblyAI Universal) on the audio conditions that actually matter for UK voice agents: 8kHz phone-quality audio, UK regional accents, Welsh place names. Full methodology, code, anonymised audio samples, and a reproducible result set.
§ 02 · Money it saves
§ 03 · How it works
- 01
Test corpus: 200 anonymised UK phone calls, hand-transcribed by native English + Welsh speakers. Covers hospitality bookings, tradespeople quote requests, legal enquiries. Balanced across regional accents (Cardiff, Newport, Swansea, English Midlands, London, RP).
- 02
Each provider is called with identical audio input via their production API. Response latency measured end-to-end (audio-in to text-out). Word Error Rate calculated against the human ground truth.
- 03
Additional metrics: cost per minute, latency variance (p50/p95/p99), handling of Welsh place names, handling of alphanumeric strings (booking references, phone numbers).
- 04
All code, prompts, and (anonymised) audio published. Anyone can re-run. Anyone can add new providers via a pull request.
Stack
§ 04 · Why it beats what's out there
Every existing STT benchmark tests clean studio audio in American English. The one thing UK voice-agent builders need — real UK phone-quality audio with UK accents — has no rigorous public data.
| What's out there | The gap it leaves |
|---|---|
| Vendor-published STT benchmarks | Tested on clean studio audio in American English. There's a massive gap between those numbers and what actually happens on a real UK phone call — 8kHz, compression, background noise, regional accents. |
| Vendor marketing pages and demo reels | Cherry-picked audio. Not reproducible. Not UK-focused. Effectively marketing, not data. |
| Nothing else public for UK phone audio | This is the wedge. First rigorous public benchmark of STT on UK phone-quality audio = permanent citation asset every UK voice-agent builder finds when they search. |